Jeremiah Lament

Not All Prophets Are Doom and Gloom

It's easy to characterize anyone speaking about the last days as "fear mongering." Prophets of the Church of Jesus of Christ provide a striking counter-example.

Popular caricatures of a prophet conjure images of a wild-eyed, overzealous man standing out in public to share a fear-mongering message of terrifying punishment to come. If that’s your idea of a prophet, Russell Nelson—a man upheld by members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints as a living oracle—will either disappoint you . . . or provide some happy relief.  

While others bemoaned the impending collapse of society, this is what President Nelson said on March 14, the week after COVID-19 shut down society: “We’re living in a remarkable age, when we constantly see the hand of the Lord in the lives of His children. Our Heavenly Father and His son Jesus Christ know us, love us, and are constantly watching over us.  Of that, we can be certain.”

After acknowledging the unique challenge we face with this pandemic and saying  “we pray for those who are suffering,” President Nelson noted, “these unique challenges will pass in due time. I remain optimistic for the future.” (If you doubt the depth of this man’s hope, watch how he responded to a plane catching on fire…yes, while he was aboard).  

President Nelson went on to clarify that his hope in the future was not unconditional – and independent of human choices between right and wrong:  “I know the great and marvelous blessings God has in store for those who love Him and serve Him” – continuing: “I promise you that joy is always within the reach of everyone who will hear Him and obey His laws….I love you.  I pray for you. And I promise that you will receive comfort and peace as you continue to hear Him.”  

It’s not just President Nelson himself who feels or expresses such hope. Other respected voices and thoughtful leaders have shared similarly encouraging messages these days – including Jon Kabat-Zinn’s wise suggestions for how to “not lose our minds and hearts when we most need them” and Pastor Francis Chan’s lovely reminders to Christians everywhere: 

  • Don’t lose your love
  • Don’t lose your joy
  • Don’t lose your peace

To those skeptical of inspiration guiding any of these leaders, it’s worth pointing out that both Russell Nelson & Francis Chan have been preparing people for years to know exactly how to feel more self-sufficient in worship at home and in smaller groups.

And against the backdrop of anxiety and despair around us, it’s striking to see the overflowing hope, joy, and love in these leaders – not despite their belief in a future coming of Christ, but very much because of their knowledge of a divine hand over all.  

That helps explain why so many Latter-day Saints stand-out as peaceful these days – with a tangible reassurance that no matter what lies ahead, all will be well. It has sometimes felt to us as if the Saints (and other believers) are the only ones who seem at peace or hopeful these days!

None of this implies we aren’t concerned about what’s going on around us. On the contrary, alongside President Nelson’s cheer, his warnings have also been plain and consistent, including this from his most recent message this very month:

Here and now, we live in a time of turmoil. Earthquakes and tsunamis wreak devastation, governments collapse, economic stresses are severe, the family is under attack, and divorce rates are rising. We have great cause for concern. But we do not need to let our fears displace our faith. We can combat those fears by strengthening our faith. Why do we need such resilient faith? Because difficult days are ahead.

He added: “The time is coming when those who do not obey the Lord will be separated from those who do.” M. Russell Ballard, another we consider to be a prophetic voice, warned in 2018:  “Unless the people of the world, and especially America, turn their hearts back to God and His teachings and His plan, we will surely face the consequences revealed over and over again in the scriptures.”

Such warnings are serious, especially with the urgency that accompanies them. If not Doomsday prophets, then, neither are these Pollyanna Prophets. They speak seriously about serious matters.  

Rather than take these kinds of examples seriously, however, mainstream media outlets continue to portray those who believe in last days events as fear-mongering by default. 

Once again, prophet leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints demonstrate otherwise.  Indeed, it would take lots of energy to listen to a message from any of these leaders and come away with evidence of fear-mongering. Even those messages specifically addressing the second coming of Christ focus largely on the hope of positive things to come (like this poignant message from Elder Neil Anderson). 

And when warnings are issued, they are always wrapped in layer upon layer of teaching, encouragement, hope, and invitation—to all. 

Not just to white, heterosexual, upper-middle-class Americans.  

To all.  

Like this invitation from President Nelson earlier this year:

Pour out your heart to God. Ask Him if these things are true. Make time to study His words. Really study!… If you are not sure you even believe in God, start there. Understand that in the absence of experiences with God, one can doubt the existence of God. So, put yourself in a position to begin having experiences with Him. Humble yourself. Pray to have eyes to see God’s hand in your life and in the world around you. Ask Him to tell you if He is really there—if He knows you. Ask Him how He feels about you. And then listen.

There’s a reason President Nelson’s first message about the virus went viral on Youtube.  People are craving hope—and not just the vague “these things too will pass” kind of reassurance—but a hope grounded in something more substantial. This is reflected in the wide array of responses that video received—from a diversity of religious backgrounds: 

  • “Salaam to all my brothers and sisters. I am a proud Muslim and I felt this message in my heart. I needed to hear these words. May we all be guided during this time of crisis. Allah bless us all!”
  •  “I’m a Catholic, but thank you my Mormon friend. Your kind words are very much appreciated. God bless.”
  • “I’m very religious however I’m baptist, but this is a very heartwarming message that is very powerful and comforting in a time like this….this is a message I feel helps many feel less anxious and more safe.”
  • “I’m a Seventh day Adventist and I approve this message!” ??‍♂️??‍♂️

Even non-religious people expressed their appreciation:

  • “I’m gay and I hate videos that religious people make but this is wholesome it makes me feel certain that we will get through this, that I love you and I’m praying for you I felt that.”
  • “I am not religious but this brought me more comfort than President Trump’s speech.”
  • “I’m not too religious but his message is needed in these times.”
  • “I haven’t been to sacrament [meeting] in awhile. I needed this message. I’m coming back.”

One other commentator pointed out what a contrast this message was from his expectation of faith leaders today, “I’m not religious and I clicked on this to see if it was anything crazy or absurd, but I’m glad to find out that it’s just a calm old man being sane and trying to support those that look to him for guidance.”

If that’s what you need—a little more guidance, reassurance, hope, and direction— join us this coming weekend (April 4 – 5) for a General Conference gathering broadcast online to hear messages of hope and healing (see viewing options here). We’d love to have you join us, wherever you are—no matter how you feel, and regardless of what you believe. (And as Latter-day Saints will attest, you can even do so in warm pajamas and slippers).  

There’s enough gloom and fear going around.  Let’s make some space for something else.  

And so we say, “Come listen to a non-doomsday prophet’s voice!”  

You won’t regret it.  

About the author

Public Square Staff

Our core team, including our Editor, Managing Editor, Communications and Media Directors, Visual Display Director and Copy Editor.
On Key

You Might Also Like

Demanding Conversations About Violence

In the weeks since the premiere of the Under the Banner of Heaven miniseries, there has been a broad consensus that the show doesn’t quite work. Its attempt to paint Latter-day Saints as promoting violence just doesn’t land. And its depiction of Latter-day Saints simply doesn’t resonate because it’s too dissimilar. This of course must come as some disappointment to critics of the Church who had hoped the series would prompt more conversations around the issues they deem problematic such as how the Church promotes violence. Into this void comes a new argument made most prominently by Taylor Petrey, but also echoed by a student columnist at the University of Utah, and now promoted on Twitter by Benjamin Park—namely, that because there has been some violence done by some Latter-day Saints who use the language of their culture in perpetrating it, Latter-day Saints should watch the series with the intent to learn how to make their Church less violent. Both Petrey and Park had previously criticized the series for its poor job in portraying Latter-day Saints, but have since shifted. We don’t want to attack the Daily Utah Chronicle piece because it’s a student article. But Petrey and Park should know better. Some of us have been on the record defending Petrey as a serious scholar, despite the fact that his conclusions don’t often derive well from the available evidence. But Petrey seems to suggest in his article that any violence that uses the language of religion must have been inspired by that religion. We understand the temptation of this point of view. What else could we blame violence on if not the culture it arose in? But Petrey’s position assumes that human beings are naturally non-violent, and only become violent as a result of their culture. This is a major assumption in the Robert Orsi essay that Petrey relies on extensively. Parks’ tweets similarly assume that any conversation about Latter-day Saints and violence must concede that the faith contributes to the violence in some way. But the causes of violence are often complicated. Because of the importance of our innate nature in creating violence, even the most peaceful society would still produce fringe examples of extreme violence. Having a Latter-day Saint who becomes violent isn’t proof that the faith contributes to that violence, even if the perpetrator uses the language of their culture in perpetuating that violence. Cultural contexts can then increase or decrease the likelihood of that emerging, but no culture has discovered how to remove it altogether. And because Under the Banner of Heaven fails to present a clear picture of what most experience as Latter-day Saint culture, it doesn’t do much to establish whether a Latter-day Saint context is more prone to cause violence than others. Those who use Latter-day Saint or another religious language and context to perpetuate violence weren’t necessarily made violent by those cultures. But rather, violent individuals will leverage anything around them to perpetrate their violence. We’re aware of many other similar examples—of abusers, for instance, who used the language of therapy to perpetuate abuse. But it would be absurd to suggest that therapeutic culture caused that abuse. Even pacifist language has been known to be used to perpetuate violence by shaming survivors into silence. An abusive person will draw upon the most powerful language available within their given cultural context and weaponize that. This is not coincidentally the conclusion made by prosecutors in the Lafferty case, that the murder was about power and relationships and that religion was merely the pretext. Does the Church of Jesus Christ disproportionately create violent offenders? We’d be interested in reading any definitive social science research on the question, but unfortunately, those promoting this point of view or hoping to have this conversation have not yet presented any. And rather than attempt to answer this question clearly itself, Under the Banner of Heaven skips the question and takes it as a given. A study of this sort could start the conversation Petrey, Parks, and the student author hope for. Instead, we get a story about a 38-year-old murder that was notable mainly for how unusual it was among the Latter-day Saint community and perpetrated by someone who had recently been kicked out of the Church for their extremist views. It should not surprise anyone that it hasn’t prompted anyone to conclude there’s a problem with violence among Latter-day Saints.

Monsters Among Us

This Halloween, the trend of American monsterizing is on full-display. Let’s recognize the fantasy in it so we can leave it behind, and avoid the danger it involves for all of us.

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Stay up to date on the intersection of faith in the public square.

You have Successfully Subscribed!