Children playing with American flags, representing LDS faith and patriotism amid Christian Nationalism.

Star Spangled Saints

How do Latter-day Saints navigate the US Constitution and their faith’s history? It’s a complex picture with both gratitude and warnings.

In July, Latter-day Saints in the United States celebrate both Independence Day and Pioneer Day. In Utah, both days are celebrated with fireworks, parades, and family time. There is also a deep religious resonance to both holidays.

Both Christian nationalism and the secular nationalism that opposes it represent threats to Latter-day Saints. It is important that we talk about the intersection of faith and country to avoid the excesses of either side.

In that spirit, let’s look at how our religious faith inspires our celebration of both days. 

The ratification of the U.S. Constitution created an environment in which (over time) the basic rights of all people could be protected, and the restoration of the gospel of Jesus Christ could take place. Indeed, we know from sacred scripture that this country was divinely inspired to bring about God’s purposes. It reads

According to the laws and constitution of the people, which I have suffered to be established, and should be maintained for the rights and protection of all flesh, according to just and holy principles; 

That every man may act in doctrine and principle pertaining to futurity, according to the moral agency which I have given unto him, that every man may be accountable for his own sins in the day of judgment. 

Therefore, it is not right that any man should be in bondage one to another. 

And for this purpose have I established the Constitution of this land, by the hands of wise men whom I raised up unto this very purpose, and redeemed the land by the shedding of blood. 

As President Dallin H. Oaks emphasizes, this revelation does not confine the importance of the Constitution to the United States alone but states that the principles of the Constitution should be “maintained for the rights and protection of all flesh, according to just and holy principles.” The inclusion of religious freedom was particularly important in providing the freedom for a new religious movement to blossom.

Religious faith inspires our celebration.

The Constitution, including the Bill of Rights and later the Reconstruction Amendments, created the context that allowed for the restoration of the Gospel and eventually ended slavery, among other major accomplishments. While the Constitution is not endowed with the imprimatur of revelation, D&C 101:77 makes it clear that God “suffered” or allowed it to be established to accomplish His goals, but also that it was done by “wise” but non-prophetic men. Latter-day Saints could appropriately view the Constitution as a major step forward toward “the rights and protection of all flesh” and the context we are expected to work with to continue to pursue goodness.

Because the right to religious freedom was guaranteed by the Bill of Rights, it created an environment that allowed Joseph Smith to establish the gospel of Jesus Christ once again upon the Earth. But as many groups have learned the hard way, the guarantees of the Constitution are not always distributed equally. Violent persecution of the Saints in New York, Missouri, Ohio, and finally, Illinois made a mockery of the ideal of religious freedom.

Not many years after the creation of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, members of the Church left to seek refuge from the very country that allowed for its establishment due to the severe persecution they faced. 

Upon arrival in the Salt Lake Valley on July 24, 1847, Brigham Young said those famous words: “This is the right place,” which filtered throughout the wagon train to other Saints as the more well-known phrase: “This is the place.”  

For the next two decades, more than 60,000 saints would migrate to Utah. Here, the Saints were allowed to grow and flourish, creating a community that provided the very first foundations for the gospel to go to the world. Pioneer Day was proclaimed as a holiday to remember these migrants and the difficulties they faced to get to the Salt Lake Valley. By 1896, Utah was admitted to the Union, and the Saints were again citizens of the United States.

Members of the Church left to seek refuge from the very country that allowed for its establishment.

Due to this experience, members of the Church of Jesus Christ are uniquely situated among religious minorities to understand both the celebration of our constitutional freedoms and the shortcomings we should continue to work toward improving.

Despite the difficulties that arose from persecution, God’s work continued to move forward in miraculous ways. Without both the religious freedoms enjoyed in the United States and the lost ‘ideal’ of those very promises that resulted in the flight west, the Church would not be where it is today. Thus, both Independence Day and Pioneer Day can serve as important reminders of God’s assurance: “I am able to do my own work.”

About the author

Public Square Staff

Our core team, including our Editor, Managing Editor, Communications and Media Directors, Visual Display Director and Copy Editor.
On Key

You Might Also Like

For This Cause Have I Been Lifted Up

In Christ’s own words of explanation for His final dark days, there are profound symbolic teachings about the glorious resurrection and perfect judgment that will follow for all of us.

Kinda Pregnant, Kinda Forgettable, Mostly Raunchy

Amy Schumer is a mood.  About ten years ago it seemed like she was about to break out as the next great all-American comedian. But her material never softened. She never found a safe sitcom to mold her jokes into something that would be network-approved. She had her hard stand-up audience and she kept it. “Kinda Pregnant” is perhaps the most Amy Schumer film yet made, and certainly the most since “Trainwreck.” If you like the Amy-Schumer schtick, I imagine you will like this movie. The film is mostly an extension of Schumer’s 2019 special “Growing,” in which she talked about her own pregnancy and her experience with it.  In this film we learn that Schumer’s character Lainy has always wanted to be a mom, but she is now forty and her boyfriend is finally ready to propose. But alas he wasn’t proposing marriage, but proposing having sex with another woman. She soon learns that her best friend Kate is pregnant. Worried that Kate is becoming closer friends with their also pregnant co-worker, Lainy tries on a fake pregnancy belly at a maternity store, and when the clerk accidentally sees her wearing it and is very kind, Lainy decides she’ll pretend to be pregnant. She goes to a pregnancy yoga class, and meets Megan who she makes instant friends with. This means Lainy is living a split life, one pregnant and one unpregnant. There is not a lot of territory left to mine in the fake pregnancy category. Between “Glee,” “Gone Girl,” “Labor Pains,” “Preggoland,” “Desperate Housewives,” and “Baby Mama” the plot device has gone from comedy to drama to action and back again. In typical Schumer fashion she goes gross-out raunchy, which occasionally lapses into a serious talk about the physical and emotional realities of pregnancy and how society treats them.  On that final front, the film does have some interesting observations. The physical realities of pregnancy are weirdly under-discussed, for a society that seems to hold pregnancy as a high honor. But ultimately whatever positive message was there falls apart for two reasons. First the film wants to celebrate family and child birth, but feels the constant need to hedge its endorsement so as not to risk Schumer’s progressive bona fides. And the entire thing is lost in a cavalcade of profanity and gross out jokes about everything from masturbation to farting. I watched “Dog Man” a few weeks ago, a movie for 8-year-old boys, and I’m honestly not sure which movie had more juvenile fart jokes.  The movie does have a few very funny scenes, but for a Happy Madison production, it’s unusually slow. And the writing doesn’t give us the kind of endlessly quotable lines Happy Madison is usually known for. In terms of the comedy, the movie is less bad and more just forgettable. The movie has a very female sensibility, given its subject matter, but it’s presented with the kind of raunchy comedy that has a smaller female audience. If you love Amy Schumer’s comedy, especially if you’ve loved her more recent materials, and you have recently had a baby and feel like no one else really gets what you’re going through, there is a good chance this movie will be among your favorites. Though I’d still recommend using a service that will clean up the worst excesses of the vulgarity—this is a film that earns its R-rating. But if you aren’t in that small group, I imagine the movie might amuse you, but otherwise it will leave you feeling insipid and put off.  One and a half out of five stars. “Kinda Pregnant” premiers on Netflix today, February 5, 2025.

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Stay up to date on the intersection of faith in the public square.

You have Successfully Subscribed!