A Cemetary with Headstones & American Flags | Importance of a Happy Memorial Day | Having a Happy and Reflective Memorial Day

The Politics of Remembrance & The Legacy of Memorial Day

Memorial Day is about remembering and honoring the dead. But it also reveals a history of conflict and the challenge of unity across U.S. history.

As a child, I remember spending a good portion of Memorial Day in cemeteries—learning about the influence departed family members and military heroes had on my life. I must confess I did not always appreciate spending the day that way. As I have grown older, I have learned to better appreciate the wisdom of appropriately remembering the past and those who sacrificed so much so that we can enjoy our present freedoms.

Prior to the American Civil War, there were no national holidays of remembrance. Historians debate when and where the first local observances of memorial days began across the nation, but they generally agree that the first national celebration of Decoration Day (as Memorial Day was originally called) began on May 30, 1868. The idea of a national remembrance holiday was proposed and championed by the Grand Army of the Republic (GAR), a powerful Union veterans’ organization. The GAR’s 1868 General Order #11 declared that the “30th day of May 1868, is designated for the purpose of strewing with flowers, or otherwise decorating the graves of comrades who died in defense of their country during the late rebellion, and whose bodies now lie in almost every city, village, and hamlet churchyard in the land. … cherishing tenderly the memory of our heroic dead … Let no vandalism of avarice or neglect, no ravages of time, testify to the present or to the coming generations that we have forgotten as a people the cost of a free and undivided republic.” Memorial Day was celebrated on May 30 each year from 1868 to 1970 when it was redesignated as the last Monday in May.

Public discourse today is unnecessarily contentious.

You might think that the recognition of Memorial Day has been free of political rancor, but you would be mistaken. In spring 1873, GAR members stationed at Camp Douglas outside Salt Lake City solicited funds from northern Utah residents to “decorate the graves of their fellow comrades” on the upcoming Decoration Day. Brigham Young and other local religious leaders made donations that offended some of the GAR members. General Patrick Edward Connor (the first commander of Camp Douglas) declared he desired only “loyal citizens to participate in the [grave-decorating] ceremony, and those of the audience who chose to come he would like to meet him at his office after adjournment” (presumably to ensure they met his definition of being a loyal citizen). The GAR post issued a resolution declaring:

Inasmuch as the Grand Army of the Republic is about to commemorate the day [Decoration Day 1873], and decorate the graves of their fellow comrades, and it appearing that Brigham Young, the President of the Mormon Church, and other leaders of said church … have contributed certain sums of money to assist in defraying the expenses of such decoration, and it further being self-evident that said contributions were not made in good faith, but to subserve the ulterior sinister motives of said Brigham Young, and whereas the acceptance of said contributions would be an insult to the memory of our fellow comrades, Therefore it is Resolved, That the [GAR] General Committee be and are hereby ordered to refund to Brigham Young and all other Mormon leaders, all moneys contributed by them for the purpose.

An increasing portion of public discourse today is unnecessarily contentious—similar, in some ways, to that petty 1873 squabble in Salt Lake City over money freely donated to a worthy cause. We can do better—individually and collectively.

Let us recognize and honor the people who have dedicated their lives and, in many instances, sacrificed their lives for us. One of those people was Father Emil Kapaun, a Catholic priest from Pilsen, Kansas, who served as an American Army chaplain during World War II and the Korean War. On November 1–2, 1950, during the battle of Unsan, nearly 20,000 North Korean and Chinese Communist forces surrounded and attacked 800 Soldiers of the U.S. Third Battalion, Eighth Cavalry Regiment. Throughout the battle, “Kapaun moved fearlessly from foxhole to foxhole under direct enemy fire in order to provide comfort and reassurance to the outnumbered Soldiers. He repeatedly exposed himself to enemy fire to recover wounded men, dragging them to safety. When he couldn’t drag them, he dug shallow trenches to shield them from enemy fire. As Chinese forces closed in, Kapaun rejected several chances to escape, instead volunteering to stay behind and care for the wounded. He was taken as a prisoner of war by Chinese forces on Nov. 2, 1950.”

We are each responsible to teach the rising generation.

He was force-marched with other detainees to the first of two prisoner-of-war camps in North Korea, where he continued to openly aid and assist his fellow captives. For his heroic actions, Chaplain Kapaun posthumously received the Medal of Honor from President Barack Obama in 2013. Part of his citation explains that:

Once inside the dismal prison camps, Kapaun risked his life by sneaking around the camp after dark, foraging for food, caring for the sick, and encouraging his fellow Soldiers to sustain their faith and their humanity. On at least one occasion, he was brutally punished for his disobedience, being forced to sit outside in subzero weather without any garments. When the Chinese instituted a mandatory re-education program, Kapaun patiently and politely rejected every theory put forth by the instructors. Later, Kapaun openly flouted his captors by conducting a sunrise service on Easter morning, 1951.

When Kapaun began to suffer from the physical toll of his captivity, the Chinese transferred him to a filthy, unheated hospital, where he died alone. As he was being carried to the hospital, he asked God’s forgiveness for his captors and made his fellow prisoners promise to keep their faith. Chaplain Kapaun died in captivity on May 23, 1951.

I would suggest that we would do well—not just on Memorial Day—to remember and respectfully honor Chaplain Kapaun and the more than one million men and women who have given their lives in American military service. Learning from their examples can help us better understand the great blessing it is to live in this country. We are each responsible to teach the rising generation and daily practice with each other the time-honored virtues of service, duty, respect, and civility.

About the author

Kenneth L. Alford

Kenneth L. Alford, a retired U.S. Army Colonel, is currently a professor of Church History and Doctrine at Brigham Young University.
On Key

You Might Also Like

Dune: Part Two

I can’t wait to watch Dune: Part Two with my kids. Dune: Part Two is so good it lodges itself (and retroactively lifts its predecessor) into the pantheon of great epic movie trilogies. Depending on whether or not the third and final installment can stick the landing, I suspect it will be spoken of in the same breath as Lord of The Rings, The Dark Knight, and Star Wars.   Like the first two of those trilogies, however, the film is not right for young children. Dune deals with serious themes such as drug use, religion, violence, colonialism, gender, and terrorism. It does so in a way that avoids the overly simplistic explanations appropriate for younger kids, but that is honest and thought-provoking. The film provides easy access to difficult conversations with teens while telling a thrilling story, and adults will leave feeling satisfied and contemplative about some of the film’s broader implications.  The film picks up in the aftermath of the Harkonnen’s capture of Arrakis from House Atreides, and Paul Atreides (Timothée Chalamet) taking a place among the local Freman. For a part two, the film is remarkably well contained with a clear beginning, middle, and end. I wouldn’t recommend coming into this film without watching the first, but if you did, you would certainly enjoy the story on its own merits.  For Latter-day Saints, the film’s most poignant themes revolve around the nature and abuse of power. Among the Fremen, Paul is believed to be the Mahdi, a Messianic figure they expect will return them to control of their lands. Paul is torn between seeking vengeance for the defeat of his family and moving on by integrating into the Fremen society. The faction of Fremen who view Paul as the Mahdi complicates this by holding out the opportunity for the power he needs to seek out revenge. The ethics of how Paul wields that potential power are among the most potent themes of the film, one sure to be further explored in the trilogy’s final installment. The director, Denis Villeneuve, is in top form here. His shots are each expertly crafted art pieces on their own merits. They lend weight to the themes he’s exploring, and he weaves them together like a composer weaving together the themes of a symphony. He even includes an extended black-and-white motif that just works. You don’t even question it.  The script is well paced. It never lags like sometimes happened in the first installment, but also gives plenty of space for its beats to breathe. It’s never confusing, but also doesn’t feel the need to over explain to its audience. Just as in the first film, the sci-fi is absurd—dragonfly-like helicopters, giant worms, and magic yelling. But the imagination here makes them feel completely authentic. You can’t help but buy in. Perhaps the most fun new element—riding the sandworms—is so thoughtfully considered it feels obvious, quite a feet for a film that wants you to buy the reality of riding a worm.    Chalamet leads a stellar cast here that has added Florence Pugh, Christopher Walken, and Austen Butler. Butler in particular inhabits the grotesque Harkonnens in a way that feels both terrifying and authentic. As for the returning cast, Javier Bardem, Rebecca Ferguson, and Stellan Skarsgård are standouts. A lot of weight is put on Zendaya in this film and she is substantially up to the task. Dune: Part Two is a great story wrapped in a world class sensory experience executed by artisans at the top of their craft. It is certainly not a film for kids, but I imagine many parents connecting to their teens over it, and I would heartily endorse it to them. Five out of five stars.