Imagine for a moment a faithful member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints scrolling through YouTube one evening. He watches one video disparaging Joseph Smith. Then another. Then another. Three hours later, he’s convinced there are things the Church never told him. Six months later, he has stopped attending church altogether.
Most people would assume this is primarily a story about church history or doctrine. Today, I’d like to suggest that it’s really a story about economics, financial incentives, and misinformation.
This article examines those questions using publicly available financial and social media data. The purpose is not to attack individuals. Critics are children of God. But by understanding the critical organizations themselves, members of the Church can better evaluate whether these organizations are credible sources of accurate, balanced, and unbiased information about the Church.
The Faith Crisis Industry
The faith crisis industry is, in fact, just that—an industry, including observable business models, revenues, expenses, and social media metrics.
When you step back and look at how critical organizations conduct business, a pattern emerges. The most financially successful critical organizations tend to follow a three-part business model. The first part is to publish high volumes of negative content about the Church on social media.
The faith crisis industry is, in fact, just that—an industry.
For example, just the six most prominent critical organizations have published a combined total of over 10,500 videos on YouTube alone, generating more than 570 million views. That number of views exceeds the entire population of the United States. And YouTube is only one distribution channel. Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, podcasts, websites, and word of mouth expand the reach even further.
Social media algorithms amplify this effect: watch one critical video, and the platform serves you 10 more. The saturation is so widespread that even those not on social media hear it through friends, family members, coworkers, and others.
Most people assume views are where critics get the bulk of their revenue. But revenue from views is minor compared with the potential payoff in donations. So the short-term goal of their videos is to produce shock, betrayal, confusion, and even anger—and that emotional trauma is a key element because it facilitates component number two: creating “community” for those impacted by their videos.
A faith crisis can be deeply painful, so critical organizations lean into that moment with a powerful message: “We understand.” “You’re not alone.” “We’ve been there.” In fact, the homepage of the website of the top critical organization says, “YOU ARE NOT ALONE,” and then suggests there is a built-in community of people you can trust who understand your feelings. That sense of belonging is real and meaningful. Community is powerful. And in many cases, members of the Church who have been impacted by critics’ content sincerely feel helped by these organizations.
There is nothing inherently wrong with providing community. The question is what happens when misinformation contributes to a traumatic faith crisis and the same organization then provides—and charges for—services intended to help people through that crisis.
For example, this same organizations’ website offers coaching services—at significant cost: $1,800 for six 45-minute sessions to help people struggling with a faith crisis. The irony is difficult to overlook. Their own videos likely played a role in creating the very crisis they are now offering to help resolve. It would be like a doctor intentionally infecting a patient with a disease and then charging that patient for the treatment.
Obviously, fees from those services also result in revenue. But once again, that revenue pales in comparison to the revenue generated by the third component: the solicitation of donations. Donations are the financial engine for organizations critical of the Church. Donations accounted for approximately 74 percent of revenue for the largest organization examined and 87 percent for the second largest.
The critics’ business model can therefore be summarized simply: critical content causes trauma, trauma becomes community, and the community provides donations. And that is how doubt is monetized by critics of our faith.
The Financial Incentives
So how much money do critical organizations make? The largest organization grew from roughly $150,000 in revenue in 2013 to $1.1 million in 2024 (2025 figures are not yet available from the IRS).
The term “nonprofit” is something of a misnomer
This is a good time to point out that the term “nonprofit” is something of a misnomer. While a nonprofit organization is not set up to make money for its shareholders, the CEO can make as much money as the board of directors allows. In the case of the largest organization, the CEO and his wife made over $308,000 in 2024.
In the second-largest organization, the CEO’s salary has been at $100,000 since 2022. His position is therefore not nearly as financially rewarding as the corresponding position at the first organization, but he still makes at least $100,000 a year producing videos that disparage the Church.
All of the numbers above came directly from these organizations’ own IRS filings, which you can see online. I use ProPublica, a nonprofit reporting agency.
The uncomfortable reality is that critics’ revenue depends primarily on donations from people experiencing a faith crisis. To continue generating revenue, therefore, critical organizations have a significant financial incentive to expand the population of church members who are in a faith crisis. Hence, they produce tens of thousands of videos specifically designed to do just that. Very literally, the more faith they shake, the more money they make. It’s a simple cause-and-effect model.
Now, to be clear, making money doesn’t automatically mean critics are lying about the Church. But the reality is that CEO salaries are connected to organizational revenue, and that revenue is largely dependent on donations from people experiencing a faith crisis. That is a critical consideration when members are faced with accusations about the Church.
Financial statements tell only part of the story. Social media metrics provide another perspective.
Critical Organizations’ Metrics
Social Blade, an independent social media analytics website, tracks subscriber and follower growth across major platforms. Based on its data, here is how major critical organizations are performing:
YouTube
Financial statements tell only part of the story.
TikTok and Instagram
The pattern is similar on other platforms. TikTok follower growth declined by 58 percent in 2025, and Instagram follower growth has fallen 49 percent year to date.
So what about other critical organizations? For the very first time, each of the six organizations most critical of our faith saw a decline in subscriber growth in 2025, ranging from 7 percent all the way up to 83 percent. And half of them saw a reduction in views gained. This is a significant recent shift within the faith crisis industry.
Reasons Critical Channels Are Losing Ground
Why are these organizations losing ground on social media? The data points us to three plausible reasons. And it is important to note that the actual reason is likely a combination of all three.
First, there has been a significant increase in the number of faithful channels that directly address claims made by critical organizations. I took a fairly random sampling of faithful YouTube channels focused on responding to critics’ claims and identified 12 that were actively producing this type of content. Remarkably, seven of those 12 channels did not exist just two years ago.
The question is not whether critics are allowed to express these opinions. Of course they are.
That growth closely parallels the declining metrics we have observed among many critical channels. More importantly, it means that faithful members and those with questions about the Church now have far greater access to accurate responses to critics’ claims than they did in the past. The conversation on social media is no longer dominated by the critics.
The second plausible reason critics’ metrics are declining is simply that there are a finite number of reasonable accusations our critics can make before their topics become redundant, and as a result, critics must turn to topics that are increasingly insignificant. For example, there are now videos about how “The Bachelorette” mentions garments and how someone apparently drove 112 miles per hour to get to church, as well as videos criticizing “Utah hair.”
One organization has also published approximately eight videos criticizing the Church’s Giving Machines, which provide opportunities to donate items and services to people in need during the Christmas season. Whatever one thinks of individual church practices, criticizing charitable efforts of this kind illustrates how broad and trivial the scope of criticism has become.
The third plausible reason critics’ metrics are declining is the critical organizations’ own behavior. The fact is that they have published some highly questionable content that call the honesty and integrity into question and may also be influencing their subscriber rates.
Troubling Organizational Behaviors
The organizations that many of our brothers and sisters who lose faith are turning to for “community” have deeply troubled track records.
Their mission statements claim their goals are to “promote understanding, healing, growth, and community for those experiencing religious transition.”
But among the videos they’ve distributed are those that threaten violence and promote drug use. And many more are intended to generate grievances.
So when we feel hate coming from comments on social media from critics’ followers, we now have a reference as to where it came from. Martin Luther King, Jr. said “Hate cannot drive out hate, only love can do that.” And more importantly, the Savior Himself invited us to love one another as He loves us.
The question is not whether critics are allowed to express these opinions. Of course they are. The question is whether organizations expressing them are the best sources for someone seeking objective information about the Church—or a healthy community during a spiritual crisis. People in a faith crisis are often vulnerable. If the community they encounter responds with hostility toward the Church, toward Jesus Christ, or toward religious belief itself, that environment will deepen rather than heal the wound.
There is nothing wrong with researching the questions critics raise, particularly when we seek accurate information from reliable sources. But that is not ultimately where our perfect knowledge will come from.
Note: This article drew on the author’s presentation at the FAIR Conference in August 2026.









