Three adult sisters and a mother share gratitude during an affectionate conversation in a sunlit kitchen.

What Our Gratitude Lists Leave Out

Gratitude journals help us remember the kindness of others. But personal thanks strengthen the relationships that sustain us.

Most of us learn the “thank you” routine when we’re small. Someone gives a toddler a lollipop, a parent nudges, “What do you say?” and the answer comes: “Thank you!” Even though we may learn that routine before we fully understand what gratitude is, we learn from a young age to respond with it.

And for good reason. Gratitude not only plays an important role in how we communicate with others but can also benefit our own well-being once we develop the capacity to experience it. Research on gratitude has linked it to a range of benefits, including better mental health and higher life satisfaction. Some research has also associated gratitude exercises with changes in brain activity.

Maybe you’re already claiming these benefits for yourself. You might have a weathered journal on your nightstand or a bulletin board by your desk where you list something you’re grateful for each day. Or maybe you set a reminder on your phone to practice gratitude or participate in a 30-day challenge to post something you’re grateful for on social media. It’s possible that when Thanksgiving comes, you even put out the decorative pillows with “Grateful” or “Give thanks” in rusty-orange embroidery.

But while all of those practices are good, what if they’re missing a key component of gratitude?

Connection with others is a fundamental human need.

Lists and journals can be wonderful, but they don’t necessarily direct our attention to the people we’re grateful to: research suggests that there may be additional benefits to expressing gratitude to someone or sharing it with someone.

To illustrate, take two imaginary examples of exercising gratitude:

Maya has a whiteboard with “Things I’m grateful for” calligraphed at the top. Each week she lists 10 new items beneath, and she reads the list often as she passes by.

Taylor doesn’t make a list; rather, each week she writes a short gratitude letter to someone. Sometimes it’s a friend or family member, but since she’s religious, she also writes letters to God.

Both are practicing gratitude. But is there a difference between listing what you appreciate and specifically thanking someone?

Choose practices that help you focus on who has helped you, not just what you have.

A study by BYU researchers and their colleagues suggests there may be. They found that reflecting on a benefactor—another person or God—fostered greater empathy and what researchers call transcendent indebtedness than reflecting on benefits without identifying a benefactor. Transcendent indebtedness involves feeling connected to someone and wanting to return their kindness freely. Those feelings, in turn, were linked to greater willingness to help others.

Other studies point to the value of sharing gratitude, too.

In one, people who journaled about grateful experiences and shared them with a partner reported higher life satisfaction and happiness than those who journaled privately or shared without focusing on gratitude.

Another study found that parents with greater attachment insecurity felt more connected after writing a gratitude letter to someone who had made them feel cherished, protected, or accepted. That sense of connection was associated with better well-being and self-reported parenting outcomes.

And a third found that expressing gratitude to a romantic partner predicted greater subsequent life satisfaction and confidence in relationships, even after accounting for participants’ general tendency to feel grateful. 

Gratitude isn’t just something to do—it’s also something to share.

More broadly, research has linked shared gratitude with better mental health, greater resilience, improved academic motivation and engagement, stronger relationships, more positive emotions, and less loneliness (see here, here, and here).

Why might gratitude practices make a difference? One possibility is that they promote more reflection. Having a conversation or writing a letter means we have to think about what someone did, why it mattered, and how it made us feel. Doing that takes active thinking and feeling, whereas listing items may easily turn into a passive, check-the-box routine.

And perhaps when we involve others, we recall more meaningful “things” to be grateful for. In the BYU study, reflecting on abstract gifts—such as emotional support, peace, or kindness—had greater benefits than reflecting on concrete items—like a laptop or car. Abstract gifts may feel especially personal and meaningful, prompting us to reflect more deeply on why we’re grateful. When thanking others, we may be more likely to recall those gifts.

There may also be a social explanation. Connection with others is a fundamental human need. When we write a gratitude letter to God or share a moment of gratitude with a friend, we may help meet that need. Sharing gratitude may help us feel closer to others, supporting our sense of connection and well-being.

So the next time you start a gratitude habit, keep in mind that part of gratitude is relational. Choose practices that help you focus on who has helped you, not just what you have.

Don’t get me wrong—daily gratitude reminders and nightly gratitude journals have their place; they can still be helpful tools with great benefits. And I love a good Thanksgiving throw pillow nudging me to reflect more on the good things in my life! But you might deepen the practice by telling others what you’re grateful for and why you’re grateful to them.

Gratitude isn’t just something to do—it’s also something to share.

 

About the author

Esther Eberting

Esther Eberting is a student at Brigham Young University studying Human Development, with a minor in Entrepreneurship. Her research and writing interests include technology, human relationships, and related legal and social issues.
On Key

You Might Also Like